Monday, March 29, 2010

Inquiry 5: "Clan of One-Breasted Women"

Like any other civil movement, Williams story demonstrates the power that we as Americans behold. As discussed before in our class, it was written in the constitution for citizens to be able to overturn the government when American's do not feel well represented. But actually initiating in that activity is easier said then done. Many people sit around and complain about things they disapprove of, but it's the people who come together and raise awareness that bring about change. The government had chosen areas of Utah as testing sights for nuclear bombs because it was more remote and uninhabited, but it was still unfair for the people that did reside in those areas to reap the consequences of the governments actions. So against their upbringing and religion, Williams and "the clan of one-breasted women" rose to the challenge of fighting for what was just. And in the end, they succeeded. When it comes to exercising our right to overturn the government, all we are taught is of the "major" movements: Black rights, Women's rights, even rights discuss by Williams. But the constitution does not limit the "significance" of what American's disapprove of, meaning it does not have to be a violation of a "major" right to be retaliated against the government, but ANY. So if significance is irrelevant what are other issues that might need to be acted against, but we feel aren't important enough to?

1 comment:

Corinne Carr said...

I agree that it definitely is easier said than done to conjure change in our country. It takes a brave person to stand up for what he or she believes in. However, I do believe that significance plays a part in the mind of each individual. There is so much corruption in the world today, so we must pick and chose our battles. Any major retaliation against the government requires personal passion for what is being fought for. I completely agree with William's reasons for protesting, for they were very significant in her eyes.
I thought one good point in Obama's speech was how Ashley "sought out her allies in her fight against injustice" rather than blaming her mother's problems on others. I think our country would be much more productive if Americans would strive to fix the problems we have rather than pointing fingers.